True, it is an acceptable comb color, but not as dark as most of what I've seen at the shows. I know she wasn't saying the bird was a show bird. Also, while the rooster is a fine looking bird, for show even a non-bearded silkie should have smaller wattles, correct?
I have a couple of smaller silkies, and one tres petite hen. One of the smaller hens weighs as much as the larger silkies I have, she's so tiny that when you pick her up you expect a featherweight, but get a butterball turkey instead.
To me it seems like much of the size is height, especially on cockerels. The problem is when you breed for width of body and shorter legs you end up with birds that can't breed naturally. Fine if you want to go AI only, but I would prefer a bird capable of fertilizing at least a few eggs on his own.
I don't mind a nice wide walnut comb, as I get the best fertility out of roosters with noticeable combs. I have one black with what I consider a lovely comb. I should take pictures.