We all do things differently and that's fine. If you don't like the advice someone gives on the forum, feel free to disregard it. HOWEVER, I personally feel it is rude to put someone down or insinuate that they are in some way harming their chick because they choose to help them in a way you may not. I am a trained vet tech who specialized in ag and small animal medicine and don't tend to give advice unless I believe it could help in some way. I completely understand that some poultry producers and owners of home flocks choose to do this on a more wait and see basis and absolutely do not fault anyone for this.
However, many chicks are born, or exposed to conditions in the first days of their lives that lead to respiratory infections. Because it is not immediately known what type of bacteria is causing the infection and treating the chick a.s.a.p. is vital to give it the best chance at survival, broad spectrum antibiotic is used.. The popping sound heard is most likely bacterial in nature and I would encourage antibiotic use in this case. I have a hard time understanding the fear of antibiotic resistance when many of these chicks will not otherwise survive. Resistance is not a typical, nor big enough documented problem to NOT treat a chick because of the possibility of it. Antibiotic is not going to harm your healthy chicks, although you shouldn't have your healthy and sick chicks together so I wonder why this is an issue? Good luck with your remaining babies.
However, many chicks are born, or exposed to conditions in the first days of their lives that lead to respiratory infections. Because it is not immediately known what type of bacteria is causing the infection and treating the chick a.s.a.p. is vital to give it the best chance at survival, broad spectrum antibiotic is used.. The popping sound heard is most likely bacterial in nature and I would encourage antibiotic use in this case. I have a hard time understanding the fear of antibiotic resistance when many of these chicks will not otherwise survive. Resistance is not a typical, nor big enough documented problem to NOT treat a chick because of the possibility of it. Antibiotic is not going to harm your healthy chicks, although you shouldn't have your healthy and sick chicks together so I wonder why this is an issue? Good luck with your remaining babies.