Or, do you think, as you sometimes come across, that people with these small properties and no allowance for roosters shouldn't have chickens?
I'll start with this.
I get accused of being anti backyard chicken keeping a lot. Sometimes it's a not so subtle dig, sometimes it's a direct insult.
I've been told I shouldn't be on the site.
I've been told that my semi feral chicken keeping arrangement as it was perceived when I was in Catalonia was so far removed from the average backyard keeper that my view was irrelevant to all intents and purposes.
Lets have a look at what evidence we have.
My model while in Catalonia was dawn to dusk free ranging essentially. This was the most common model in the area of Catalonia I lived in. It applied to rural and those few remaining suburban keepers.
https://www.backyardchickens.com/threads/feed-management-methods-poll.1533521/
The last five options in the poll are pretty much the same as my keeping arrangements in Catalonia.
Forget about the secure word in the poll. You can't free range for 8 hours a day and be secure. In fact you can't free range at all and claim to be secure. It's a misleading poll option.
As I write this there are 113 votes in total.
51 of the votes are near enough to how I kept the chickens in Catalonia.
51 of the votes. Almost half the vote total.
On the evidence I'm not so much of an outlier as some have suggested.
What's more, the advice I might give is going to be relevant to that percentage of the identified free range and semi free range keepers.
The standard backyard chicken keeping model as currently promoted on this site isn't in many instances.
The next three options working up the poll are for time out of the coop and run keepers. They account for a further 22 votes. This is how I am trying to care for the EX Battery chickens; out every day supervised for a couple of hours if possible.
That's 76 votes out of the 113.
It seems to me that I'm more representitive of the majority of those that have voted than those who advocate the fully confined backyard model.
Yes it's important. The advice for a number of topics from broody hens and hatching to feeding and welfare is different for the two models if the welfare of the chicken is the primary aim.