- Thread starter
- #7,891
Good post. I think my view isn't well balanced currently. There are so many problems that need dealing with at the allotments and so few resources that what's best for everyone rather than the individual is what I'm left with. This isn't necessarily the case for others.Yes, I saw that and am glad for @ManueB and for Caramel.
It has been an interesting discussion and stirs up some emotions. It comes at a tough time for me as I am treating, maybe over-treating, a sick pullet and am consciously making the euthanize or keep treating decision every day. It is hard.
The extreme cases are much easier.
It is the cases in between that challenge us the most and as @GregnLety said, sometimes you just need to follow your heart. Hopefully that 'heart' is informed by experience or advice from others whose intent is good and who have some knowledge (whether they are a vet or not).
- A vigorous chicken who gets a superficial wound - I am sure we would all clean it up and treat with some sort of infection prevention spray/cream
- An elderly chicken who after a long decline is lethargic and clearly in their final hours - I am sure we would all agree with @Ribh that the kindest thing is to keep that chicken calm and in a familiar place and let nature take its course
- A badly wounded chicken in pain with no prospect of recovery or repair - I am sure we would all agree that euthanasia is the kindest thing to do
And the ex-batts may be the hardest group of all for whom to decide these things. To accept that they will die soon is not the same as seeing them as a dead chicken walking.
I think we would all agree that even an ex-batt with reproductive issues deserves a dab of Vaseline to help her with her scaly leg mites. Probably also OK to add extra protein to help her through a tough molt.
Those are easy because, maybe with some help from people here, we can figure it out for ourselves and can do the treatment ourselves.
But what if we don’t have those skills or knowledge? If we have the means to consult someone with more knowledge (a vet) and there is one available, should we deny the dead hen walking ex-batt that service?
A couple of examples come to my mind. One is an abscess near the eye. It is likely to look awful and cause pain. Left untreated it can lead to death in a variety of ways. I am guessing only the most experienced would be confident in their diagnosis (vs a tumor for example) and even fewer would feel confident in wielding a scalpel to relieve the pressure and remove the pus and cure the animal. I would take that chicken to a vet if I could.
Another is impacted crop that has not cleared with the usual at home remedies. Crop surgery can work. It can be done at home. But for the faint of heart that is another example where a vet could intervene and return that hen’s quality of life until. Again, I would go the vet route if I felt the vet was competent to handle it and I could afford to do so.
I think my point is that these are very individual decisions. Each chicken is different, and each individual’s circumstances are different. I think it is fine to have some principles to help guide these decisions, but I am wary of anyone who believes they know the answers.
So, bravo to Manue for having the courage to hear our conflicting views, and bravo also to her for following her heart.
And of course, all best wishes to Caramel..
I understand I have now likely over-stayed my welcome so I apologize and I am off out to assess quality of life for my poor sick Bella.