I'm really under-qualified to advise on this matter -- this is my first experience with multiple cockerels. 33 pullets is a whole lot more than my 5 hens & 1 pullet to 4 cockerels situation. I know there's a few keepers here who keep multiple roosters -- I think
@Perris has 3 or 4 roosters and only 16 or so hens, but he has multiple coops.
@Molpet keeps multiple roosters across 4 coops and all in one big poultry yard.
@GregnLety has several roosters with separate housing arrangements and I think rotates their ranging time somehow. And
@Shadrach relates that in the
specific scenario of his Catalonia keeping circumstances the average tribe size was 4-8 hens with 1-2 roosters.
From all the reading and mental note taking I've done about this, the only conclusion seems to be that there is no conclusion. Everything depends on the keeping arrangements. And it appears that keeping roosters/cockerels in a more multigenerational situation (with senior and junior roosters respecting a hierarchy) is easier than keeping several the same age.
I still plan on keeping Lucio (10 months old) and Tobias (5 months old ) as his junior. We'll see but Tobias seems a natural "second lieutenant type. He knows he isn't a a fighter like Lucio and his short legs keep him from catching hens by force. So he uses treats. And sometimes a hen crouches for him.
Hopefully out of the 4 chicks here now, there's at least 1-2 pullets...
I just couldn't see any way that 4 mating cockerels and 6 females could work without more hens getting injured and hiding in the forest. And I'm not going to bring in a bunch of unknown females and go through quarantining and introductions just try to appease animals that likely won't do what I would hope for anyway. I want to keep allowing my tribe(s) to expand organically via broodies hatching chicks here.
If you don't my asking, I'm just curious, what is your keeping circumstance like?