Everyone is assuming (naturally, I guess) that Chuck is HUGE.
He is actually smaller than the hens he's causing feather loss on. I picked him because he was small and tidy. He's an Easter Egger, and the size of a regular hen. He is smaller than Blanche, the Buff Orpington who is so slow she can never get away from him and he is smaller than Dorothy the Blue Laced Red Wyandotte who is also so slow she cannot get away from him. And these are the two with the most feather loss.
I just read a article/thread on this forum by another Rooster expert - they said that hens who
like their rooster should squat for him when he initiates.
HAH, well, none -- absolutely ZERO of the hens squat for Chuck. He has to chase them down, grabbing them and forcing himself on. NONE of them squat. I didn't think anything of it. Which is interesting because before we introduced him (we had separated all the boys for months before choosing one) ALL of the girls squatted for me and my husband when we just walked by.
Most of the girls run away and he has to surprise them by stalking from behind.
Now he does have cuddlers on the roost at night, 2 others, Easter Eggers, interestingly. (Pudding and Custard, and mostly Custard)
You know what's interesting, and curious about
@Shadrach 's hypothesis? Neither of them have feather loss. What is also true about Pudding and Custard is they are fast, small, and wily and *independent* and do not spend all day with the flock at all. They 100% do their own thing all day long.
So that could mean that they don't get 'caught' by Chuck very often, so no feather loss. Whereas poor Blanche and Dorothy, more 'typical' chickens who are not independent and also very big and very slow, are more easily caught, so overmated and thus; feather loss. Chocolate is now showing signs of it and she's the third largest chicken and about the same size as Chuck.
Also with regards to 'squatting' - I have observed a couple of hens squat for Oscar.
Since I have 24 acres (the chickens are left to their own devices and on it, use about a 6 acre circle of it at the very most) it will be also interesting to see what happens.
I have chicks who are 4-5 weeks old and have been brooded on the floor, with everyone, since 1 week old, I let them out. None of the other hens or cockerels coming up care or do anything to them. They are all alive. In fact I've done this in successive waves, so there has been chicks growing up with teens/adults/adolescents all spring and summer long. Everyone's still alive. For most of them, there was no broody to protect them. They did fine with their 'safe' space only they could retreat to -- interesting thing??? They barely use it. They LOVED being with everyone.
Most of the time, when I go out in the heat of the day, everyone who is still young enough to still hang by the hen house, even though their ages range from baby to 10-12 weeks old (this seems the age when they begin to range far), they are cuddled together sunning or dust bathing. All ages together.
I chalk this up to the fact that they have space. They could leave the run area, the door is wide open. They don't. They hang out together against the Big Scary World until they are 'big' enough to go with the grown ups.
Anyway regarding Chuck; regarding my flock in general; I could throw a rock and hit 5 people willing to kill a rooster for a meal, so finding someone to take any unwanted roosters off my hands is brainless and easy. I just don't want to do that. I have a contact who re-homes and just keeps bachelor flocks on her property. She and I have already set up an agreement that she will take any spares I don't want.
But I don't want to arbitrarily toss boys who don't need to be tossed. But I will need to get down to 5 boys. Only 4 of the ~13 boys I have right now are sexually mature. I want to see how Batman, Miss Pecky and Cocoa behave.
I will continue to assess the watch the featherless girls, I will assess and watch the new cockerels coming up and see if anyone actually prefers (squats) to them.
I don't know if anyone has bothered to read
my thread but I keep it quite updated with my situation and I have an entire bachelor set up already. It's just close (I mean, within 500 ft) to a neighbor and I feel terrible about the crowing at 4am lol