Hey wishing you might want to try Waltham butternut if its for the chickens and you have a hard time with pumpkins that or Amish pie pumpkins...small but I find they are easier to grow. You can usually toss those seeds right into a compost pile and they just do the work themselves....I've got plenty of butternut this year. I did have an issue with pumpkins of the giant variety because of bad squash bugs this year. If you want to try again next year I could even send you some seeds that might work for you. Pumpkins are supposed to be easy to grow they just take up a huge amount of space in the large variety. I grow some ornamentals in containers some years. I'm excited for next spring to be able to grow for these little ones. I even kept some small cabbage in the garden for them to have as treats this winter. I had a watermelon sitting here but forgot that they aren't supposed to have treats so young.....guess pie will wait for next year for the girls.
That's a great idea! I'll look around for seeds for pie pumpkins and butternut. Pretty sure I can find some that will work here. There's an heirloom seed bank in the next town over. But in case I can't find any, thanks for your offer! Our summers are dry, dry, dry so inconsistent watering may have played a huge part in my pumpkin failure.

As for treats for young chicks, I think some things are ok in moderation. If a mama hen was raising them, she'd be offering them all sorts of goodies from day one. When my chicks were 2 weeks old, I showed them how to eat aphids off of kale leaves.Yummy! They ate the leaves too! No problem. Stick to natural stuff, no bread or cake, but you could probably make them a mini-pie of chopped greens! If you do give them anything other than chick starter, make sure they have access to grit needed proper digestion. Be prepared for them to be scared and suspicious of anything new!
Any new pics of the babies? Have you figured out any of the mystery breeds yet?