Rooster on the left is really nice. Nice comb even. Again, can't see the width of chest because of the picture, but no one advertising ever thinks to put those head on shots in there.
The rooster on the right has a poor tail angle, what might be called squirrel tail even. The tail is supposed to be at a 45* angle from the body, and his tail is at a 90* angle from the body, coming up and over his back. Otherwise he is a nice rooster also. This could just be a bad picture, you need to see in person if he really has a tail that carries at that angle, or if he was startled etc by the photo session. I've taken one or two pictures of my Rooster that show him in that posture, but he definitely doesn't have a tail that he normally carries at that angle.
Laney