Jeremy, they are evil little heart stealers for sure! Can't say you weren't warned, can you? They really are wonderful. Isaac is amazing. He minds better than my dog does and loves chest rubs. And the three girls I kept, Georgie, Ellie and Maxie, are the most loving girls. Georgie pulls on pants legs, Ellie scratches on pants with her feet and Maxie hops up to whatever is closer to your face and chases you back and forth to get your attention. All three love being held and cuddled. They are real people-chickens.
As far as the little one, if it can't get to food and water and is having that hard of a time, yes, I'd euthanize the poor baby. You can certainly give it more time, though. I think you'll feel when it's time. As far as a pigeon toed one, I'm not sure if that is a problem or not. If it's walking okay, may not need any boots. And the legs may straighten out as it grows--some are so crammed in their eggs, they seem to have legs that aren't quite straight for the first week. That is, if I'm understanding what you mean about it.