I have a hen (standard cochin) with full size spurs. She is now two years old and she has only laid one egg and that was about a month ago. The roster is shore she is a hen though and she is one of his favorites. I think this is a hormonal fault - sometimes genetic but sometimes caused by the lack of a rooster. In my case it is definitely genetic since they have had a roooster present all the time. A hormon fault could also explain why some lay eggs and other doesn't and why there can be severe cases where they turn in to rooster. i wonder if those hen / roosters are fertile. I would guess not.