What gender is the chick?
Yes, Id/id+ can look the same as Id/Id
If the rooster carries id+ then I would expect about half his daughters to show dark legs, no matter what color legs their mothers have. If the hens all have light legs, then all sons should also show light legs (although they could also carry id+ if the father has it.)
Have you hatched very many chicks from that rooster?
I don't know exactly what gender it is, but I would guess female based off of the genetics, and that some of it's brothers are showing combs now. All of the cockerels I have do have light legs.
I have 9 chicks from that rooster right now, about the same age as the one pictured. It's the only one with dark legs. I think there may be at least 3 other females fathered by the rooster, all having light legs. I'm guessing this is just numbers getting skewed by a low rate of offspring, and if I hatch more I will probably see more dark legs pop up.
Thank you for the information, knowing Id/id+ can look the same as Id/Id helps a lot for future reference.
That double nail and feathering makes me think it's part silkie
The chick I showed is smooth-feathered, just scraggly looking because it's insane.
I haven't seen the double nail yet on any of my adults, but I can double-check later.
I'm assuming you're right on part silkie though, and that's where the dark legs came from. My rooster and one other hen have one or two vaguely silkie-like traits, so I assumed if there was a cross it was a few generations back. Of the things i'm breeding away from, it just slipped my mind that the rooster could've been Id/id+.