I've been reading these posts on all 3 threads today, and agree with a lot of what I'm reading here. I raise both EEs and BBS Ameraucanas. I feel fortunate that the first chicks I ever hatched were properly labeled Easter Eggers, and I knew the difference between the two from the start. I never had the incur the wrath on the other thread while being informed I was wrong about my chickens, as I seen so many others suffer.
The feed store in my town sells EE chicks every year labeled as Araucanas. Because of this, there is a rampant misunderstanding of EEs, Ameraucanas, and Araucanas in this area. The feed store doesn't know any better. They label them as the hatchery tells them to. What I don't understand is why more hatcheries don't adopt the term EE? EEs are colorful, sweet birds with colorful eggs. What's not to love? I realize they're trying to make a buck, but I never have any trouble selling my EE chicks, especially when folks see the eggs. I breed for egg color. We're not all trying to breed for show, and there's nothing wrong with that.
Our local feed store actually labeled theirs Ameraucana/Easter Eggers this year. I think that some feed stores don't know very much about chickens and like you said just go along with what the hatchery is calling the chicks. I think they should at least list them as non-standard Ameraucanas and inform people that they aren't "show quality." Easter Egger seems to include a lot of different crossbreeds of chickens that may or may not lay a blue egg. I think the hatcheries breed there chickens based on their blue egg laying abilities. I guess they could just advertise them as "blue-egg-layers." It seems like that type of chicken falls into no-mans-land. It doesn't have a distinct title or classification. To be fair, a lot of the hatchery catalogs that I received this year did state under the Ameraucana breed description that they should not be used for 4-H. So to me thats an indirect way of say non-standard birds that will not meet the SOP for the breed. Maybe we as the buyers just have to be smarter and properly research what we want to get. I was the same as you I understood that unless purchased from a breeder the Ameraucanas I was purchasing at the feed store were probably going to be EE's or non-standard blue egg-layers. Which is absolutely fine by me! I just feel sorry for people who think they have purchased an Ameraucana and then as you said "incur the wrath" from members on the other thread. Thats why I created my new Ameraucana thread today. I am trying to get more people to subscribe. I'll post the link below.
https://www.backyardchickens.com/t/...discussed-apa-non-standard-and-project-birds/