I'd kill for Mr. Nice to come live down here. But I know the feeling with too many roosters. I've got Hollywood the Silver-laced Orpington, and Suede the Blue Orpington. I guarantee both of the older Silver-laced are roosters, Sterling Jr. (for now) and his white-legged brother. And I have Derek the Recessive White Orpington. That's five boys. I only have three Silver-laced hens, Mel, Sue, and Victoria. I have Dahlia the Black Orpington. And the Weird Sisters, Prudence, Agatha, and Dorcas, the Chocolate, Blue, and Lavender pullets. Oh, and Odette the Recessive White Orpington and the two youngest Silver-laced Orpington pullets.
I snapped some decent pictures of the crew this weekend. I'll get them posted from my phone in a bit.
Back to your Lavender Dilemma...
I'm not a huge fan of Wonky although I will say that he has the correct amount of points on his comb. I noticed all my Lavender cockerels had six or more points. I prefer five to six, but that's a preference. Both five or six points are allowed per the Standard.
I like August but I think he has too many points. It's a little hard to make out because he's not well developed in the comb area.
How old is Mr. Nice? Is it worth replacing him, or hoping to see if you produce another nicer cockerel from him next year? I'd be tempted to keep him due to the comb issues with both the younger boys.