The color name issue is tender for some folks. For me and my rose combed birds, I get lots of people here and on facebook thqt tell me they will never be pure, even though they breed with more consistancy than many of the 'pure' clb's out there.
Remember, the legbars are like lamonas in the fact that we know how they were made since it was fairly recently and they are just a composite. Luckily chickens are judged on their phenotype so it does save some headaches
I am very glad you are developing the rose comb variety. I have always thought of them as a Rose comb project Cream Legbar and agree with everything you have said.
Over on CSU they talked about Delawares and how there is a breeder basically re-creating them from scratch because the Dels had drifted from the original type and were looking mighty washed-out and off-type. Will hers be 'real' Delawares? I vote yes but some might argue. I have also been on the 'what breed is this' forum and had folks argue that someone's hatchery quality whatever was a mutt because it wasn't 'remotely' like the breed but I could still tell it was a Barred Rock even though not a very good quality one. So yes, there are about as many opinions as there are people and some are, shall we say, very vigorous about their opinions.
I remember Nicalandia musing that he had thought about re-creating the CL from scratch. Now some may argue that because you can't replicated the hen brought off the boat from the Araucana Indians that the Secret Sauce will be missing and that you can never get a 'real' CL from scratch. I would argue that you could get South American Composites and get pretty darned close (especially being as how he is in Nicaragua, they wouldn't even be composites).
So to each there own. There are arguments to be made on both sides and I figure this is meant to be a fun hobby and try not to take things too seriously. I certainly am not going to get my panties in a wad about stuff unless someone is crossing the line and actually mis-representing a sport as APA accepted or selling Cream Legbars as pure that are gold, have no crest and lay brown eggs (ie are clearly not just bad examples of the breed but are cross-breds). If 'you' don't think that a Rose comb on a Cream Legbar is right then you are welcome not to buy that project line!
Last edited: