Hi Chicken Picken,
Thank you for the response. I am no longer defensive about Sunny's color, and I didn't feel slammed by you at all. When I was asking questions in the "Alternative SOP" thread, I was really trying to get people to break it down for me. Where is he "too colorful". I appreciate your feedback.
I am not interested in breeding all of the color out of my flock, at least not yet, as the breed develops, I do want a more consistent color. I am not sure about the Chestnut on his chest, or if that is shadow, going to have to check. He does for sure have orange and yellow under his neck in his hackles.
Clarifying question, when you say say "no color" on the chest, do you mean just gray and white barring, or something else. I noticed in this picture he looks a little more "brown" that he looks in real life, including his tail.
I have 2 boys just coming into their rooster feathers, who are beautiful, but seem to be carrying more Chestnut, my next batch is a little too young to tell. I will post pictures soon.
I completely agree I would like each generation to be better than the last.

However, I have grown probably too fond of Sunny!

I would like to mention, in my experience this breed creates some of the best flock roosters I have ever known. They are protective, beautiful and easy to handle. Sunny feeds the chicks, watches over the flock with diligence, and is always the last chicken in the house, after his hens are in. My friend has tells me her rooster does the same. It is part of what endears me to the breed. When I do retire Sunny, I sure hope I can find someone who wants an awesome flock rooster.
I am not breeding the color out yet, as I love some color in there, but I am watching how the breed develops, how the first shows go, and to get a better definition of "Cream". I will make further decisions from there. There are a lot of things to improve on in the meantime.