*Big sigh*
Okay... let's solve this argument.
-I don't think we all have to abide precisely by the books. It's easier and more fun to make some things up, but certainly to a point. Like Tarbd mentioned, not everyone has read the books. That doesn't make them ineligible to join. If we had to follow it precisely, I'm sure Michaelmay would've said so.
-Tarbd, don't yell. I understand you're upset, but your yelling could set someone else off.