Fiesty is a tad bit off color. I think I'd like that. It would help me to tell her apart from the others. I put a lot of stock in good egg color myself. She might not win in the show ring, but if she lays lovely eggs, what's the harm? You never know, she might throw perfectly colored chicks once you cross her to Moose.
On the other hand, I have 2 hens that are perfectly colored AND lay gorgeous eggs, but they aren't even in with a rooster. I wouldn't consider breeding them because I got a lot of feather stubs on the legs from that line. That's my pet peeve. Wretched feather stubs! One hen has them and the other doesn't, but still I wouldn't risk it. I sure do love those big bold eggs though. Beautiful.
Anyhoo, your birds are lovely. I have some from Bargain also, and they do lay nice eggs. Your Moose resembles my Beauregard. Very handsome.