Kim, were you at the show this weekend?
There was a good number of Welsummers at the show this time. I was pleased to see that. Now before I go on, I'd like to say that if the person who had the Welummer pullet at the far right is on this thread, please know this is meant as no offense and that I would have really liked to have talked with you in person but wasn't able to locate you.
Having said that, the bird in mention I have to think was a hatchery bird. Without going into anymore details, let me just say that if anyone ever had any question about the difference between a hatchery bird and a good breeder bird... well, you know what they say - a picture is worth a thousand words. It was like night and day and a great testimony as to the difference between a breeder bird and a hatchery bird. I would've liked to have taken a picture of the bird along with others there as a visual aid but I didn't wish to offend. And if the person who had that bird is on this thread, please let me know as I would be happy to help you get started with some nice Wellies of your own. We all have to start somewhere and I am just glad to see you have an interest in this great breed. Please take no offense and please do contact me if you would like some of my Wellies.
Just for everyone's information, Erhard Weihs took Best of Breed (BB) and Champion Continental with a very nice Wellie pullet. Erhard and I went down the row and made our grades prior to the judge. We were not only in total agreement but we came pretty close to the judges actual grading. The only difference is that the bird we had as #1, the judge put #2 and the bird we had as #2, the judge put as #1. When I talked with the judge afterwards, in a nutshell she basically said that the bird she chose as #1 over the other was because there was "just a bit more too her". After quite a bit more discussion I was able to determine that the bird she picked was a little heavier and had a bit more body to her. Something Erhard and I hadn't considered because we didn't pick the birds up. I still think the bird we chose as #1 had a bit better overall type and definitely carried her tail better the majority of the time.
I don't recall now just how many birds total there was in the Continental Class but there was a bunch. I took 1st amongst the Barnevelder males and BB overall but there was only like a half dozen Barnies total. I think there was some Polish and other breeds but I just don't recall now. At any rate, there were quite a few in the class.
Back to the Welsummers, the females seemed to have been in better overall shape than the males at this show. One male I noticed had a dual-colored hackle, another had little to no mottling, one was DQ'd for leg-color, one had quite a bit of fluff at the tail, and the wattles on another were larger than what I would want on mine but that isn't saying anything as I believe it was still acceptable by the SOP. Both Erhard and my cockerels were just too small to be in the running although both should do well in March if they continue to develop without any unforeseen problems.
For what it's worth, I did have one nice, large male that I would've liked to have taken but somebody bit his middle point out on his comb several months ago.
If I had to make one comment from my critique of the Welsummers I saw at the show, it would be that we all MUST work on leg color. This is my #1 focus right now with my Wellies. And, just so you know, I say this with the utmost humility but even though I would say my birds had the best leg color of all the Wellies there, they were nothing more than slightly yellow. Erhard's Champion Pullet was a real dandy and a very fine looking bird and I would not take anything away from it but even though it made Champion Continental it still did not have the yellow legs that I would like to see on a Wellie female.
One last thing regarding leg color, I know that diet has an affect on leg color but I am absolutely convinced that genetics play a much greater role that what folks are allowing it to. I say this because of what I've seen in some Welsummers of my own and because of what I've seen in some Barnies and Buckeyes. I have one Buckeye female, for example, that has legs which are almost orange. And that is no exagerration. She gets the same exact feed as everyone else so it must be genetics. I read some time in the recent past the the yellow leg color is a recessive gene. That means it is even more important that both the male and the female are contributing the gene to their offspring. I have NO idea what kind of alleles or modifiers - or even how many - there may be that also have an affect. That is why I am just going to focus on only breeding the male and females with the deepest ochre color I get.
God Bless,