They can handle a lot more than many people realize, but they can also get into trouble. There are a lot of different things that come into play as far as brooder temperatures go. Number of chicks, breed, size of chicks, their diet, type of bedding, how draft free is it actually, and many other factors. Nobody knows what all of your actual conditions are. The guidelines given on here are intended to keep practically everybody out of serious trouble practically all the time, assuming they are sort of following standard practices.
Since we all have different conditions and circumstances, following the guidelines exactly does not absolutely guarantee success. Not following them exactly certainly does not guarantee failure. The guidelines are intended to improve your odds of success, not guarantee anything, but they are slanted to help people be on the very safe side. For most of us they are overkill. But for a rookie starting out, it is nice to have very safe guidelines to go by.
In most cases, chicks five weeks old are fully feathered out, so they can handle pretty cold conditions. Exactly how cold depends on whether they really are fully fearthered, how draft free the coop actually is, whether or not they have been acclimated to cooler temperatures, how many there are, and who knows what other factors.
About the most miserable I've ever been from the cold was when I flew from 90 degree weather to where there was snow and ice on the ground with a wind, although I was properly dressed. A lot of people don't appreciate the importance of acclimating the chicks. To me, that is a huge advantage of brooding out of the house in a brooder big enough that one corner can stay warm but the rest can cool off a lot. I'm offering this as an example of how we have different conditions. The guidelines say they are normally fully feathered at five weeks and can handle the cold, but if you have not acclimated them and the temperatures are pretty severe, and your coop conditions are not reasonable as far as draft protection, even the guildlines may not work perfectly.
Or you get the flip side of this. I had a broody take her 2 week old chicks to the roosts with night-time temperatures in the lower 70's. Not all could crowd under her to stay warm. By the guidelines, they should have bee in trouble, but they all made it fine.
Until you get experience, I suggest trying to follow the guidelines. As you gain experience, you will better understand what you actually need to do in your specific circumstances.
Since we all have different conditions and circumstances, following the guidelines exactly does not absolutely guarantee success. Not following them exactly certainly does not guarantee failure. The guidelines are intended to improve your odds of success, not guarantee anything, but they are slanted to help people be on the very safe side. For most of us they are overkill. But for a rookie starting out, it is nice to have very safe guidelines to go by.
In most cases, chicks five weeks old are fully feathered out, so they can handle pretty cold conditions. Exactly how cold depends on whether they really are fully fearthered, how draft free the coop actually is, whether or not they have been acclimated to cooler temperatures, how many there are, and who knows what other factors.
About the most miserable I've ever been from the cold was when I flew from 90 degree weather to where there was snow and ice on the ground with a wind, although I was properly dressed. A lot of people don't appreciate the importance of acclimating the chicks. To me, that is a huge advantage of brooding out of the house in a brooder big enough that one corner can stay warm but the rest can cool off a lot. I'm offering this as an example of how we have different conditions. The guidelines say they are normally fully feathered at five weeks and can handle the cold, but if you have not acclimated them and the temperatures are pretty severe, and your coop conditions are not reasonable as far as draft protection, even the guildlines may not work perfectly.
Or you get the flip side of this. I had a broody take her 2 week old chicks to the roosts with night-time temperatures in the lower 70's. Not all could crowd under her to stay warm. By the guidelines, they should have bee in trouble, but they all made it fine.
Until you get experience, I suggest trying to follow the guidelines. As you gain experience, you will better understand what you actually need to do in your specific circumstances.