... I never ever lose any sleep over keeping my chickens safe at night ..Having a secure coop and locking it at night really should be the priority.
Same here, I don’t worry at night about raccoons ...and I agree with the secure coop idea ...
... but I also agree with the OPs thought that reduced numbers means a reduced chance of problems...
I see it not much differently than preventativly removing mice before they infest and tear things up...
...infact it always kind of stands out to me that we never see any “live and let live...” comments on the mice and rat related threads of BYC....
Preventativly removing raccoons is a viable strategy...I’ve done and it works.... before removing the raccoons, there were multiples in the yard every night, tearing up bird feeders, consuming a large amount of sunflower seeds, “rearranging” flower pots, digging in garden areas, etc....
...now when I set a trail camera out at the coop...I only occasionally see one....but our mulberry tree will fruit soon so that will likely change soon...
... as I mentioned previously, raccoons are hard on wild quail, turkey, and other ground nesting bird populations, so there is also a benefit to them that comes from reducing the raccoon numbers ( which are often artificially high due to living around people)...
... we enjoy seeing deer and other wildlife in our yard and do not wish to have a dog to keep chicken eaters away as it would keep other wildlife away, but that might be another strategy that the OP could use to keep raccoons away...
... so removing and reducing the numbers via preventative trapping is simply a strategy we’ve used to manage the raccoon population on our property...to me it makes more sense and has more benefits than removing them on a case by case basis...
... but again I would recommend that the OP become familiar with the local laws concerning this first... because many places require proof that the critter was causing issues before being removed... unless you are trapping in a designated season with a trapping permit.