Welsh Harlequin egg counts from Holderread vs Metzer

Discussion in 'Ducks' started by nobueno, Mar 9, 2017.

  1. nobueno

    nobueno Just Hatched

    10
    1
    14
    Oct 30, 2016
    I was getting ready to order some Welsh Harlequins, more than likely from Holderread's. They claim their flock of Harlequins are averaging 260-350 eggs per year, Metzer's claim they're only getting 100-150. Has anyone done an actual comparison between ducks from the two? I mean I understand their estimates varying a little but by 160-200 eggs per year!? I'd pay a little extra initially to get potentially 3x the eggs from my ducks. Could Holderread's selective breeding have lead to the difference? What gives?

    Those of you with Harlequins, where did you order from and about how many eggs are you averaging per year?
     
  2. moosehornstream

    moosehornstream Just Hatched

    9
    0
    12
    Jan 17, 2016
    Maine
    I'm getting Welsh Harlequins this spring from a private breeder, so I don't have personnel experience yet, but everyone I've talked to around here, (in Maine), says theirs average 280+ per year. I saw Metzers stats on the 100-150 and I didn't think that was right... JMO
     
  3. Ducks4us

    Ducks4us Chillin' With My Peeps

    1,548
    207
    186
    Mar 31, 2015
    North Idaho
    I dont have any welsh harlequins. However i kinda think metzers puts the minimum eggs your duck may lay or something? I dont know. They have the lowest numbers listed for all the breeds compared to what i have read in books and heard from others.
    The only ones they have high numbers listed for are khakis, and the golden 300, and white layers.
    I know people who have runners from metzers who say they are fantastic layers tho. So ?
     
  4. Krazyquilts

    Krazyquilts Chillin' With My Peeps Premium Member

    I think I was somewhere that at Holderread's, high egg production is one of the traits they select for for Welsh Harlequins, but that really high egg production may not be as important a trait at some of the bigger hatcheries.

    I do that if/when I get more Welshies, it will be from Holderread.
     
  5. apricotvalleywf

    apricotvalleywf Chillin' With My Peeps

    194
    32
    91
    Jul 28, 2014
    Millbrook, Ontario
    My Coop
    If the Holderreads claim that number, then they have performed egg trials to confirm that number. Metzers and Holderreads produce a very different bird.
     
  6. learycow

    learycow Chillin' With My Peeps

    2,485
    320
    246
    Apr 1, 2011
    Southern Maine
    Metzers lay 300-350 per year. I have raised TONS of their birds over the years. Quality for showing isn't there, buy from Holderread if that's what you are looking for. 100 is LOW and likely a typo
     

BackYard Chickens is proudly sponsored by