what's wrong with using a shocker? nothing more than a whip or crop both used for years in training horses, shock collars on dogs is quite common and not considered inhumane
danstirringsomethingbecauseit'sslowtoday
as other folks say, IMHO all of the above are only used by those who either lack the intelligence to be able to out think their "students" or too inhumane or indifferent to care how cruel and unnecessary any of these methods are. In my past I have trained both, including guard animals, successfully, without the necessity, to shock, whip (as in beat - popping for sound or tapping to get their attention is no different than snapping your fingers at your child) or otherwise inflict physical pain and/or injury.
FRENCHIE - training by "soring" is totally unnecessary, it's just easier than the right way. Refer to above remarks.
Training (control) animals thru fear of pain destroys all trust and can come back to bite you, literally.
Yes I agree 100%.... (did it sound like I thought is was ok at all ???? Nope !!! I don't) I also don't like the elevated shoes... I saw them used first hand by a guy in Rhinelander who had a horse show a few years ago. He bred purebred Morgans and did his own shoeing!! I swear the shoes were 5 inches tall... Real heavy... You can't tell me that their backs don't get misaligned by that..... I think the shoes were only put on the front or at least taller in the fronts.... H3LL if my prosthesis is off by 1/8" I can feel it.
In natural horsemanship using a crop or (in Parelli world) a carrot stick is ok. (Parelli describes this as a cross between a carrot and a whip) The carrot stick is basically used as an extension of your arm. Horses have a hierarchy going on and if you watch them you will see them take nips and kicks at each other. They do this once or twice and get the message across. They don't keep at it... The horses at the lower end of the hierarchy learn to respect the ones on the higher level. This is what natural horsemanship is all about. You establish your role as the leader. That is why a person can be taken full advantage of by some of the best trained horses out there. They haven't learned the "language" of the horse and the horse literally walks all over them. And this all starts on the ground aka Ground Work.
Same with the Pot Belly Pigs. You have to continuously "Move the Pig" in other words, speak their language to maintain your higher level of authority. Same thing, if you don't the pig will get the reputation of being a bad pyscho pig when all it was doing was looking for a leader.
Believe it or not horses do not like to be the ones in charge !!! But if they feel vulnerable and unsafe because you are not stepping up to the position they will do the honors !!! Then they get the reputation of being a bad horse or untrained animal ready for the auction.
They can sense a scare D Cat mile away. So to protect themselves (since they are a prey animal) They become the leader. So by learning THEIR languale and using the "carrot stick" you can reach the horse from a distance and give him a "nip" in his hindquarters where ever is needed to send him/her the message that You are the Alpha. But you can do all of this from a safe distance.
As far as lunging goes .... as long as we're on training topics.... all you are doing is making a horse's muscles stronger and if he is an idiot he/she will be a stronger idiot. It's all about communicating with the horse !! So many people (riders) think that all they have to do is groom the horse, hop on and go on the trails or enter the show and everything is fine and hunky dory then wonder why their horses act up on the trail, won't cross water, spoke at things, cars, bikes, sirens etc.
Parelli says, "If you can't do it on the ground you can't do it from the saddle".
People need to spend even more time doing ground work (no not just lunging) with the horse then riding.
If you've ever seen any of Parelli's videos you would see people from wheel chairs communicating with their horses.... I get goose bumps everytime I see it.
It is so sad to see the horse so misunderstood in so many ways. My mares favorite words are "Boobies Boobies"! All I have to do is say Queen, lets do boobies and she is right there, postitions herself so I can get up personal and close by her side and we scratch her boobies and in between them.... She love loves loves it. A black waxy stuff comes off on my fingers (it's between her boobies) and every time she has to sniff it when I'm done !!
Anyway, now that I went off on that tangent I best get dressed... Yep, I'm still not dressed or put together yet.... Driving to Wausau and back yesterday wore me out... Gotta go back next Wednesday. So next Thursday I'll be beat !!!! Might just go to Olive Garden by myself if ET has to work.
Ok, I'm out of here !!!! Gonna go see what ET is doing for me on this special day !!!! Where are you Tomski ????

.
exactly! I have preached since I was young that intelligent humans learn to speak and UNDERSTAND the language of their animals. Stupid humans expect animals to immediately understand us they are also the ones that are quick to resort to violence to illicit obedience instead of taking the time to help them understand.