I don't have any experience with roosters as of yet so I can't really help on which to keep. That being said.... While both are handsome I really like the looks of Big. Now a question... Just because Big is the non dominant right now, his personality MIGHT change but it's not a guarantee is it? I mean, it would be good, if you were to keep him that is, to step up as a dominant now that the other is gone but it doesn't necessarily mean that he'll go from dr. jekyl to mr. hyde right? It CAN happen, but doesn't mean that it WILL? And can't you just reassert yourself as alpha and put him in his place? Now plz understand, I know I am WAAAAAY SUPER SIMPLIFYING. So basically I'm saying that I guess you'd have to ask your and decide if it would be worth your time and effort if that situation were to occur, right. That make sense? What other worst case scenarios am I not thinking about? Again, I don't have any experience with roosters as of yet so I'm curious.