Also keep in mind it is OUR duty to guard our birds, you can't fault other people for not training their dog to leave prey (chickens) alone when they don't own them (honestly, legal or not shooting a dog over a chicken is just silly), again it is YOUR respnsibility, and mine as flock owners to defend our flocks.
Yes... but... you >>>>CAN<<<< fault other people for letting their dogs run loose to terrorize other people's pets and livestock at will, especially those that have been caught doing it previously. Anyone who thinks their dog won't return to a farm where they had fun chasing and killing a chicken (or a cat or a sheep or a calf... etc) and do the same thing again is fooling themselves. It's not the dog's fault (it's just instinct), it's the owners fault. People need to take responsibility for the actions/outcomes of their dogs' behavior if they are allowed to go off their property unsupervised. And while it might seem "silly" to shoot a dog over *a* chicken, you have to consider that rarely just one chicken is killed but more often it's several, sometimes an entire flock decimated, and what are the chances that the owner will handle the dog any differently in the future? Consider the "going rate" here locally for a young laying hen or one about to lay, which is around $12-15 depending on the breed. I like dogs just fine, but I can tell you that once I've lost a couple of birds at this value and have to look at reinvesting money and possibly waiting months (paying for feed in the mean time) for them to be productive, the option of shooting the dog starts to become much more plausible and necessary since our local animal control/law enforcement folks have no role in it. Also consider pack mentality if dogs run in small groups, killing an entire *large* flock is a definite reality. This adds up to hundreds of dollars very quickly, as well as the loss of valuable genetics for so many people. The other concerning thing is that often times when a dog is caught in the act, their adrenaline is going so strong and they are so caught up in the moment that it can be impossible to get them to cease and desist, no matter the yelling/throwing stuff/ect to try to get them to stop, and shooting them becomes the only way to stop the carnage. I personally have spent well over $1000 in fencing, chargers, and materials to build secure coops, and I just hope the dogs never get through. I seriously doubt that any of my neighbors with dogs running loose have any appreciation for the money we've put into our flock, and they would indeed go ballistic if their precious little pooch got shot for such behavior, but I also seriously doubt that I'd ever get reimbursed for losses by them either, without taking them to court. Yes, I do keep a .22 and a shotgun by the back door, for whatever needs arise, and in my mind, that (as well as our fencing) is just me defending our flock, just as you say, it's indeed my responsibility, for sure. I will try my hardest to resist any further ranting on this topic, but it is a serious pet peeve of mine and a big problem where we live. You could argue that dogs don't kill livestock, it's their *owners* who allow it to happen, sort of like guns don't kill people....