Ok, I will take a stab at this. The cockerel is not too bad. I would not be overly worried about color at this point. He seems sort of small and a bit shorter legged, but, overall is clearly the best of the lot. If it were me I'd use the cockerel if I didn't have a better one, but I would only breed him to a female of excellent type. The pullets honestly I would not breed. They just don't seem to have good Cubalaya type to me. The bottom one in particular has a very pinched tail. I would not put any of those pullets with that cockerel just because I think getting anything good out is unlikely. Not impossible, but unlikely . I would try to find better birds. Now, I am not basing any of these statements on the color. Just on overall type. I use plenty of imperfect birds on my end, but I try to have one bird of each pair be of good breed type. When I don't do this, most the resulting chicks turn out pretty poor. If at at least one parent is good, usually some of the chicks are good typed if not colored. I'm not trying to be mean it discouraging, just honest. I know I will have a white male to part with after this season that is of good type and color both.
That's just my opinion. I'd welcome Doc or Zachs input here .....
That's just my opinion. I'd welcome Doc or Zachs input here .....