TillyD

Songster
Jun 1, 2022
122
140
113
Hello! This is anecdotal, but when I was searching for info on dry hatch VS "traditional" I couldn't find this... So, I'm gonna put it out there.
I have hatched both ways and I wanted to share my technique for both, and the experience. I have the Kebonnix 12 egg incubator.
For traditional hatch, I held my incubator at 50-55% humidity and 99.5° for 18 days, then at 65-70% after lockdown. I weighed on day 1 and day 18. Eggs lost 9-12% of their weight. Of the 9 eggs I put in on day 1, 8 seemed viable on day 18. 5 hatched fine. 2 pipped but did not zip, and I did not assist the hatch because by the time I noticed the pipping, the chick had passed. Pipping began at the end of day 18,most hatched on day 19, and all that were going to hatch had hatched by mid day on day 20.
For dry hatching, my humidity varied from 25-35%, but the temperature was the same, consistently 99.5° F for the first 18 days. I weighed in days 1, 9 and 18. By day 9, eggs had lost 7-10% and on day 18, they had lost 12-18% of their weight. For lockdown, I raised humidity to 65%, and kept it between 63% and 67%. Pipping did not start til day 20, and hatching was mostly all at once on day 21, with one straggler coming on day 22. I had 8 eggs again on day 18. 7 of them hatched, with no assistance needed for any of them. All 7 are healthy and doing well.
For me, dry hatching was easier (no chasing humidity for 18 days, didn't need to add water!) And the hatch rate was better. Dry hatching seems to take a little longer, but the success was worth it!
Attached are pictures of the chicks from my recent hatch at 1 day old. Please feel free to add questions or your own experience with dry vs traditional hatch. 😉
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20220801-151842_Marco Polo.jpg
    Screenshot_20220801-151842_Marco Polo.jpg
    271.3 KB · Views: 67
  • Screenshot_20220801-140026_Marco Polo.jpg
    Screenshot_20220801-140026_Marco Polo.jpg
    156.6 KB · Views: 12
  • Screenshot_20220801-151602_Marco Polo.jpg
    Screenshot_20220801-151602_Marco Polo.jpg
    282.8 KB · Views: 11
  • Screenshot_20220801-151641_Marco Polo.jpg
    Screenshot_20220801-151641_Marco Polo.jpg
    240.3 KB · Views: 11
  • Screenshot_20220801-151657_Marco Polo.jpg
    Screenshot_20220801-151657_Marco Polo.jpg
    323.3 KB · Views: 13
  • Screenshot_20220801-151719_Marco Polo.jpg
    Screenshot_20220801-151719_Marco Polo.jpg
    261 KB · Views: 13
  • Screenshot_20220801-151817_Marco Polo.jpg
    Screenshot_20220801-151817_Marco Polo.jpg
    335.6 KB · Views: 13
I’ve never attempted a completely dry hatch, but just add very minimal water every so often that it’s almost a dry hatch. It consistently stayed around 30% the whole time, even in my dodgy incubator. I then added more for lockdown and it stayed between 60-65%, worked perfectly, 5/6 hatched, the other one was infertile but was an olive egg so hard to see through, I think the main thing was consistency of humidity.
I definitely prefer a drier hatch, as it’s far less stressful, and for me is much more successful.
 
I will report back to this thread soon... I have 34 eggs due to hatch on Fri Aug 5th, using the dry-hatch method in a Little Giant foam incubator. This is the first time I've tried it, driven to find out what the heck is wrong with this incubator that previously most of the chicks died after pip but before zip.

I also have a Kebonnix using the traditional method, and with each hatch there are a few I have to assist. It shouldn't be this hard.

So I'm anxious to see what happens on Friday.
 
Hatch is coming along nicely, I think. Seventeen in the brooder doing great - but 17 still in the shell, some in progress pipping or zipping. Getting anxious about the rest.

I'm trying to keep the humidity constant 70-80%, but it's a struggle. Having to adjust the window openings to vent sometimes, other times dribbling a little water on the paper towel "nest" I made surrounding all the eggs. I'm also still rearranging their position in the incubator (NOT turning, just moving one spot to another) to attempt to keep temperature consistent for all the eggs.

Here's our "early bird" - hatched a full day ahead of any of the rest:
1659752377524.png


And some of the others, hatched so far today:
1659752417676.png


The white chick at far left is the "early bird." I LOVE the black streaks on the backs of some of the red ones! Too cool:
1659752465625.png
 
I will report back to this thread soon... I have 34 eggs due to hatch on Fri Aug 5th, using the dry-hatch method in a Little Giant foam incubator. This is the first time I've tried it, driven to find out what the heck is wrong with this incubator that previously most of the chicks died after pip but before zip.

I also have a Kebonnix using the traditional method, and with each hatch there are a few I have to assist. It shouldn't be this hard.

So I'm anxious to see what happens on Friday.
I will be waiting to hear of your success! 😀
 
I’ve never attempted a completely dry hatch, but just add very minimal water every so often that it’s almost a dry hatch. It consistently stayed around 30% the whole time, even in my dodgy incubator. I then added more for lockdown and it stayed between 60-65%, worked perfectly, 5/6 hatched, the other one was infertile but was an olive egg so hard to see through, I think the main thing was consistency of humidity.
I definitely prefer a drier hatch, as it’s far less stressful, and for me is much more successful.
Completely dry, the incubator hung out, mostly, above 30, so I didn't want to add any water... I live in a coastal city, and ambient humidity was often in the 50% range. 😜 I would definitely not let it go under 25, since I was comfortable with the weight loss and air cell sixes/movement with the range I had, and wouldn't want any more weight loss or larger cells.
 
Hatch is coming along nicely, I think. Seventeen in the brooder doing great - but 17 still in the shell, some in progress pipping or zipping. Getting anxious about the rest.

I'm trying to keep the humidity constant 70-80%, but it's a struggle. Having to adjust the window openings to vent sometimes, other times dribbling a little water on the paper towel "nest" I made surrounding all the eggs. I'm also still rearranging their position in the incubator (NOT turning, just moving one spot to another) to attempt to keep temperature consistent for all the eggs.

Here's our "early bird" - hatched a full day ahead of any of the rest:
View attachment 3212999

And some of the others, hatched so far today:
View attachment 3213004

The white chick at far left is the "early bird." I LOVE the black streaks on the backs of some of the red ones! Too cool:
View attachment 3213008
Oh my word!!! Cute little nuggets there!!!
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom