So my theory could have been right earlier when I mentioned the vitamin suppliment. So hopefully it isn't momma. But we are having an interesting weather day, several tornado warnings, I went storm chasing earlier. LOL!! After this system passes, we are really info high probablity of power outage, they are calling for winds high as Hurricane Cat. 2 winds. Something Michigan never hardly sees. So, fill the tub up, got blankets next to the HB to cover it, and hope that these babies will hatch. I am pretty certain I lost 1, because there is no rocking, no pipping and where there would be a pip, the entire ring is getting really dark. So, once all of these babies hatch and dry and there is no pip, I think I will candle the last one for any movement or cooling to the touch, and if there is any sign of life, pip it then and wait and see. All 4 babies are getting the other 3 eggs going, but nothing to the 1 that isn't showing anything hopeful.