Bee, you and I have chatted here for a long time. You know my thinking as well as most folks, I hazard saying. We've been working with (H) Barred Rocks now for over three years. We started off a base of GSBR (pretty fair layers in their own right) and have kept that line pure, but I've been working really hard at a cross with a fork of the Maine line. What I am seeing is incredible type. SOP, near take to the show beauty. Do I enjoy that? Sure. But, and this is much more important to me personally, is that the meat creation is simply outstanding. There was a carcass shown earlier by UphillJill. Perhaps most important to me is intelligence, temperament that is calm, business like and eager to forage, but also willing to be confined during our horrid winters. That Big Grey Book lays beside my easy chair and yes, it gets studied regularly.
I absolutely demand quicker maturity, both in body size and egg laying starts. I want a quality, large egg and I want to see a consistent 4-5 eggs per week. Frankly, the pullets are knocking out 5 eggs a week. I am pleased as pleased can be. I feel the strain needs another year or two of work for feathering precision, as that is important to me, but I won't sacrifice the virtues of this venerable breed, America's most popular on the farms and homesteads of the century past.
It's all what you breed for, seems to me. Within the century old DNA of these Rocks is all the makings of the breed as the birds once were. To breed for 10 years, blinded by the sheer desire for egg production would make these birds into something they never were intended to be. But, to breed for slower, slower, and slower maturity because one is enthralled by the beauty alone that such slowness often creates but all else (maturation, egg laying and vigor) is sacrificed on that altar is a gross injustice to the breed and nonsensical vanity in my book.