My older DD lives in the historic cottage home district by Arsenal High near downtown Indy. Her neighbor a few doors down has chickens and a roo, and they surprisingly fit right in and don't seem loud-- maybe because of blending with typical city-related noises. Because of that aspect, backyard chickens may make better neighbors in cities.We live in the city--6 miles from downtown Indy--and we hear roosters crowing. We don't have any, but the sounds are coming from at least 2 different directions in our neighborhood. No neighbors asked us if we minded hearing roosters crowing.
In a city-sized lot, if the rooster was right next door, I'm afraid it'd be considered a noise nuisance.
Two years ago, when we were surprised with cockerels, I found that even after we rehomed all but one, his crowing (all hours of the day) drove me crazy while I was trying to work in my home office in a fairly peaceful neighborhood. I personally like to hear a rooster crow-- in the distance! haha
I agree with several of you that polling neighbors may lead to more problems. It could cause conflict between neighbors who disagree and might snowball into general noise complaints concerning a neighbor's dog, truck, leaf blower, screaming kid, etc. etc. Then you might be forced to leave the neighborhood. hahaha -- just joking about that part, but my point is you can't please everyone, so you might as well not ask! I do believe in being a considerate neighbor, though, so IMO, I'd see how keeping a roo goes and if you think it's becoming a stressful situation, you could rehome him-- and of course it would be advantageous to set up a rehoming option beforehand.
Last edited: