Is this true??

Historically in the U.S. the two largest egg markets were the New York area and the Boston area. New York had a preference for white eggs and Boston a preference for brown. But there was also the broiler market to be considered. Up until about the nineteen fifties or so chicken meat was mostly a byproduct of the egg industry. They had to have something to do with all those cockerels and spent laying hens. A plucked Leghorn is the original rubber chicken. Real egg laying machines, but not much to them when it comes time to eat them. This was a major reason why many of the great American breeds were developed. They laid well (brown eggs though) and they grew large enough to dress out to something when slaughtered.

But that was all fifty years ago or more so things have been steadily evolving since. Now broilers are their own dedicated breeds and have nothing to do with the commercial egg industry which in the U.S. has mostly gone over to Leghorns because they are simply more efficient and thus eggs can be produced more cheaply. Unless you're eating the shells it's what is inside the egg that matters so folks gradually went over to buying white eggs because they were cheaper. The spent hens went into soup cans though even that has now largely come to an end so the birds are mostly just composted now. These last ten or twenty years brown eggs have made something of a comeback as the sex-links were developed so that they didn't have to waste feed on unwanted cockerels and the hens became more efficient layers. White eggs still predominate though.

I'm not as familiar with the U.K. and the European markets. If you were to go into a typical supermarket in those areas do they have more white eggs or brown eggs?
 
we rarely get white eggs at all but i think thats because most eggs are now free range, i do believe most English prefer brown. I haven't seen a white egg for ages.
 
the only reason i prefer brown eggs at the grocery store is because they come in paper pulp packages..... the white eggs come in styrofoam packages and i hate that stuff, it's not recyclable around here and probably stays in landfills for hundreds of thousands of years. that seems to be the general rule around my area: white eggs=styrofoam, brown eggs=paper pulp, organic/cage free(expensive) eggs=plastic (which i prefer over the styrofoam also).
 
Quote:
We have both white and brown eggs available in the stores up here but the bulk of the product is white. The brown ones are more expensive and have the same consistency and flavor as the white ones (watery and lame). I think people get a warm fuzzy from buying brown eggs, or it might be a status thing.

hmm.png


I will continue to grow and eat my own at an insane rate. I have a friend who is a cardiologist. I do it for him, I'm his retirement plan.
 
My experience is that people prefer and are willing to pay more for brown even if the white eggs are farm fresh and live with the brown layers!

As for blue/ green eggs, I can't ever keep them - I could sell 10 dozen a day if I was able to have 150+ hens! (Notice I said able, not willing!)

Someone started a rumour years ago that the blue/ green eggs were lower in cholesterol, and even though my research shows that it is NOT TRUE, I still hear it from people I sell to!
hu.gif
 
Yeah, totally no difference other than shell color, but yeah, I've heard lots of people say they love or don't like, either or the other for all sorts of odd reasons. (dirty, chickens eating bugs, (and that's a bad thing?
roll.png
) they're 'spoiled', taste funny etc etc)

I myself grew up with hens that laid brown eggs so when I moved away, if I occasionally would pay the extra money to have brown ones if I was a little homesick or nostalgic, but I never for a second thought they tasted different.

I read somewhere that egg companies set up the whole 'white' egg preference simply as a marketing ploy, just after WWII and it stuck. I think it was a part of the whole 'modern' attitude in the 50s, it was the beginning of the big store, forget about where food really comes from thing! Now people think they're "better" out of ignorance. A friend in upper Mass tells me there's lots of brown eggs in her stores, and throughout the rest of the New England area too and lots of people prefer them. Here in Ohio, it's possible to find brown eggs in stores but it's just a little section of the shelf with maybe two rows of brown eggs, and they cost considerably more.

Just another thing that makes you go Hmmmm!
 
Last edited:
Brown & Green eggs here, I still occasionally get a white egg from my flock of mutts. The Green/blue ones are in greater demand here among our egg buying friends then any other. Most people here do prefer the grass and bug eating henfruit.
 
Apparently it depends on what part of the country you live in: some areas prefer brown, others white. Generally nonchicken people think of white eggs as commercially produced whereas the brown ones are "farm" eggs and, therefore, better. I've noticed the local super market chain--which has there own egg laying operation--sells only Omega-3 and/or Organic in brown eggs. I suspect there is a reason behind this as they (Wegmans) are good at marketing.
 
Quote:
This.
Beached flour and white eggs. "The farm" was where a lot of folks wanted to escape from, and wanted to prove they were more modern than the folks back home. Then for a while, they were all that were available in the stores.
 
I always figured that the biggest egg season was Easter, and the white eggs dyed better.

I think more people will be purchasing brown eggs because the mind set now is to return to 'the purity' of the farm.
But I agree: White rice, Bleached flour, and white eggs. It was the penthouse food. Now, we think of all of that 'whiteness' as unhealthy. Will white shelled eggs now get a bad rap? Wait, egg already got the bad rap in the 80's with them being cholesterol bombs. That has changed now too.

People spend too much time being putty in the hands of advertisers.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom