Yes, I would agree. Lavender as Moonshiner says is a dilution gene that affects both the black and red pigments. Andalusian uses different genes.
Agreed -- it gets confusing and to the eye it looks more lavender than blue -- so why muddle things up with nomenclature?
Andalusians are not that common any more are they? I may have to do some digging.
Those blues are different from the effects of lavender gene. And they are different genes. I got a quote to put in -- but not sure it will shed a lot of light. Do Andalusians come in black or splash?
The just want to make us crazy actually. -- LOL -- There are hobby names for colors and genetic names for colors -- but the gene according to the chicken calculator is lav...and as you said recessive.
Here's something from my newest book on Genetics:
"The blue gene (Bl) varies greatly in expression, from pastel "powder puff" Blue to a mid-Blue, right through to a very charcoal Blue, with many shades in between these three examples " under three photos of light, med and dark blue chickens pg.74 in the heading The Complexity of the Blue gene. Book is
21st Century Poultry Breeding by Grant Brereton.
Also on that page:
"In such varieties as the Andalusian, the Blue Orpington, and the Blue Australorp, a distinct dark lace is required to surround the blue interior of the feather. This was thought to be made possible by the presence of the combined Lacing genes of the Laced Wyandotte being present in an otherwise self Blue fowl(Carefoot 1984).
The Blue gene was always thought of as largely 'unpredictable' in relation to the particular shade it produced when present in single form. The Mendellian laws of the Blue gene have long been established and two copies of Blue gives a splashed appearance, no matteron whar background.
So why the varying shades? In my opinion, the Blue Gene is consistent in expression, but relies heavily on the quantity of Black pigment present in any given fowl to determine its particular shade. If such Black genes are purified within a strain it is likely the shade of Blue produced will be consistent regardless of the particular shade itself. " P74
21st Century Poultry Breeding by Grant Brereton.
SOOOOOOOOOOOOO --- probably for our lavender projects/breeding there is a similar consideration of the strength of the Black genes that are being diluted by blue -- AND the presence of Mahogany gene to make the hackles 'pop' for our mixed color birds. I guess is a person is aiming for a lavender leghorn that has no added colors it would be a black unpatterned starting point with lav. gene added.
Which circles me around to a couple of things. (See if I'm clear on these Moonshiner)
1. We may -- have to introduce the original non-lavender colors from time to time in out crosses to keep the vibrancy of plumage. Many generations of lavender without an outcross MAY produce faded looking birds.]
2. Very dark pigmented blacks will enhance the lavender portions of our birds
3. Mahogany will enhance the 'red' portions of our birds.
And just wait until we get into -- gold and silver in the mix.
ETA -- found internet answer to the question I asked TheMoonshiner:
Blue Andalusians lay white
eggs. They are very active and great for free range and foraging situations.
Like all blue fowl, they produce black and splash offspring as well as the blue color.