I am fairly positive that with my dead chick problem it was the non broody's that killed the chicks. I felt horrible for the broody moms. =( Every other year I keep chicks in with the other chickens and have never had a problem, but this year I think my moms are just too 'nice'. All my broodies let me handle them and maybe that's translating to being too wimpy and not able to scare off the more dominant hens.I wonder what causes a hen to kill her chicks...I have chicks due to hatch in the next few days *fingers crossed* and she is first time broody so I'm a little worried. She is in the corner of a shed with only her friend another silkie and my unstable drunken roo. I just have my fingers crossed that I have a good hatch and she doesn't kill them.