Shouldn't This Be BLUE?!?!?!?!?

[rosemarysugar]

Hi
I have 7 hens, 2 white layers, 2 dark brown layers, 1 light brown layer, 1 cream layer, and (SUPPOSEDLY) a blue egg layer.

Ok, here is the story. All of the hens I just told you about are good layers eggs except for, the cream layer (who doesn't lay anymore) and one of the dark brown layers (who, will drop a fairy egg about once a month).
Then I have my blue egg layer, she is an 11month old brown-red americauna who has NEVER layed!!!!
So anyway I go out side and find a medium sized reddish-brownish egg with spots/calcium lumps all over it (none of my hens eggs ever look like this one). Could it be my SUPPOSEDLY blue egg layer's egg?!?!?!?!?
COULD IT BE HER'S???? I felt her abdomen and it feels a little swollen and her pubic bones are a LOT wider.

If you have any questions about the egg, flock, or chicken her self don't be afraid to ask. The first photo is the mystery egg the second photo is a normal egg,the mystery egg,and a fairy egg.Third photo is mystery egg cracked.

 

[sylviethecochin]

An Americauna? As in an EE from a feed store? If so, high probability of that being her egg.

 

[jonezjollyfarm]

Are you sure shes not an ee? Some times they are advertised as an Americanna and they are really ees. I know mine were and are actually ees all green layers though. And one of my roosters is an ee and he carrys the brown egg gene.

 

[Chickassan]

Yup if it is an easter egger you can get the much coveted and very exiting BROWN! Happy Easter kids!

 

[andreanar]

Show us a photo of your girl in question. Side view while standing if you can.

 

[rosemarysugar]

An Americauna? As in an EE from a feed store? If so, high probability of that being her egg.

She is from Murray McMurray

 

[Chickassan]

Need a photo, good possibility it is going to be a really brown easter.

She is from Murray McMurray

 

[rosemarysugar]

Show us a photo of your girl in question. Side view while standing if you can.

 

[rosemarysugar]

Show us a photo of your girl in question. Side view while standing if you can.

 

[Brahma Chicken5000]

View attachment 1578234

Yup that’s an Easter Egger.