Yeah, our discussion was in the fact that we really don't know what makes the Tolbunt coloring, or at least the mottled part of it, we just know that it is not the same as other mottled birds, however Whitehackles often have a lot of similarities in the fact that the coloring is genetically not the same as mottled, and it is often pretty uneven. (white or smudged looking tail, wing, and neck feathers, etc)
I know you game owners consider Polish like Silkies and the rest, but to me, a well bred one (to the APA's SOP) is actually a nice, robust bird. The common hatchery Polish however are in most cases
- Skinny, ugly, not too bright, and not very hardy.
Personally I love the naked neck of Madagascars and Turkens, however I don't think Madagascars make for good crosses. The head and body of one suits it so well, makes it so beautiful and powerful looking (in my opinion of course! ha ha ) - Taking away that head, the slight wrinkle, the dewlap, and the low set tail angle ust makes it look, umm, odd. Even Turkens shouldn't have the American Gamefowl-type bodies. (upright, large tail, thin, lightweight looking body, etc)