Oh my goodness your black one is beautiful! And your right it does have that "handsome" look about it haha. This gives me hope about my one white one who im convinced is a roo but I am hanging onto him till I know for sure because as it grows its crest is getting super thick and its comb is still flat at almost 8wks so I am hoping it could actually be a girl!I would agree that you have at least 1 x roo there. It becomes easier to pick in your own lines but there's always 1 that will keep you guessing.
This little guy was obviously a roo from about 5 weeks of age.
This one on the other hand had me convinced it was a roo, and then it laid an egg last week.