Backyard,
It would cost you nothing to use the PM system here for reviews. We are all in this together and want to help each other. My best reviewers are my family, but sometimes I don't agree with them. However, their opinion is always free and candid, so I can always take it for what it is worth, or not.
I usually have a pretty good idea if the soap is a winner or not. One time I made a soap that 2 family members told me was slimy. I agreed with them and did not repeat the recipe.
All that being said, are we going to include both our BYC personalities and our real names or just the BYC names we are known by?