She has always been very flighty, unlike all of my other EEs and any pure Ameraucanas I've had. She squawks like crazy when touched and is just not generally very personable. Probably not the best choice to let her rear these chicks, but I'm hoping that if I take them away in a couple of weeks they'll be more people-oriented than she is. I had a few cream legbars and one of them was super flighty, so much so that she escaped and lived in my woodpile for about 2 months before I finally caught her. She escaped a second time and never returned. I wasn't too beat up about it aside from having paid through the nose to get her from Greenfire Farms!
Most owners have had a preference for the seemingly mellower Ameraucanas over their cousins the EEs. I know the sinking feeling of paying through the nose for a breed only to lose it. I invested over $300 total in buying one rare juvenile bird, paying shipping costs, vet bills, nursing it, and still having to put it down after only one month! The companion bird purchased with it was sent as the wrong sex and had to be re-homed. Needless to say, I won't be dealing with that breeder ever again! Poultry raising is a risk at best but inept or deceptive breeders ruin it for the hobbyists.
It never fails to amaze me at how 1% of a breed can be so different from the other 99% - my theory, and IMO only, is that the multiple breeds used in a bird's breeding history can never assure a common temperament: i.e., Dominiques have been left basically un-engineered for decades/centuries whilst the corresponding BRs (an off-shoot of Doms) has had Indian game bird (Cornish) and Malay cross-bred into them to make them larger and more dual-purpose. Because of the wilder temperament of their ancestry I've had BRs pop up with some pretty aggressive tendencies while most will inherit the sweeter temperament of their Dom roots.
Just a personal theory, mind you, but I see it happen in breeds that have Leghorn cross-bred into them (like the CLs) - Leghorns can be a very assertive to downright aggressive bird - my folks and I have had them in big flocks. LUV Legs but they haven't done well in our mixed breeds flocks. Legs are popular to cross with other breeds to increase productivity.
And BRs create most of the newly popular Auto-Sexing breeds - again exposing new breeds to the aggressive ancestry of the BRs. Most BR crossings will inherit the good Dom ancestry genes but there's always the scattered chance of the wilder temperament history emerging in Auto-sexing. Breeders can try all they like to breed out the aggressiveness in their stock but there are just certain breeds I stay away from when I know what their breeding ancestry is on the off-chance that the one bird I get will have the trait I dislike. Some breeds I feel will always have a certain temperament, like Silkies, and because they are bred in volume in all colors there is a high chance of getting one oddball but on the whole they are pretty consistent. Whereas a dual-purpose like a Welsummer or Barnevelder who have so much diverse breed ancestry it is "iffy" as to what temperament will emerge. Lucky if you get the good individuals but sad to raise a bad seed only to cull or re-home it later. True, raising birds is a challenge and have to be selectively bred, but IMO there are just some breeds that are what they are no matter how much work is put into improving them.
Sorry, I rambled a bit off topic - but it solidifies how we narrowed our choices for the breeds we ultimately chose to keep in our small backyard.
Anyone have any input regarding SFHs? Temperament, productivity, size, weight, flock compatibility, human interaction, etc?