your understanding on genetics is very limited, and thats why you are not understanding the issue at hand in the USA...
in the USA. there are good colored males and females, but we are also seeing "Dark" Barred males and Darm females hatching and to me knowing whats the issue is the beginning of the solution of the problem. I belive thess birds have "all" it takes to be as good colored as the UK(have seen very good birds in the USA)
that Rich colored male you see in Green Fire Farm is not due to the lack of the cream gene(gold diluter) or due to single barred birds.(single barred wont dilute gold) but due to the fact we are seeing two type of Barring genes, Dark Barring and Light Barring. now if more information is know about these genes, one could breed for light colored chicks and expect better colored males. but color is not everything, Type is about the most important thing in a breed. so I say keep the rich colored birds and breed for type untill further notice
yes im not near clued up in genetics as maybe some of you guys
but the cream legbar was a 20 year long refinement by punnet
and the nature of the breed and the auto sexing ability should be as I have seen here as simple as get a good quality male specimen and a good quality female specimen and due to its years of refinement and breeding true abilities
the offspring should be true and pretty much correct without leakage or decolouration
The only thing I see Is somewhere down the line a glitch in the breed has occurred and its unknown to the breeders
it happened to me once
I brought from the same breeder buff orp eggs and lemon cuckoo eggs
seems his cockerel was playing hookie as my buffs all hatched out as lemons
one issue that could possibly happen and this is only an example im not saying it has happened
it is something that happens in UK
a cotswolt legbar pullet thinking its pure due to is striking resemblance is bred to a pure cream legbar cockerel and the breeder thinks they got true breed cream legbars
but infact they are not
its even possible a Bielefelder was used somewhere as the desired plumage is cream Legbar Plumage on them
I had a hybrid cockerel fathered by a Cream Legbar and mothered by a RSL and only a good keen eye could say it was a hybrid Legabar
Don't get me wrong we all want to learn and refine the breed and as your trying to figure it we all are and only helping each other can achieve that
Think of it like this
3 people walk in at the same time into a Labtynth
one turn left one turn right and one goes straight on
all 3 go through this maze and hit dead ends need to turn back go another way rethink their strategy
and ultimately they all need to get to the centre (and its not a RACE)
would it not have been better for the 3 of them to stick together compare strategies take each other opinions and get the that same goal the centre of the maze in half the time and together
same with breeding
rather than go your own way to get to the same ultimate goal. why not work together to get to that same goal and help on the way
after all the end product needs to be same so why add ingredients in a different order just add them in the same way