I agree with you rc50
back on my soap box
I'm really not going to listen to someone in the UK tell me not to breed a bird. I appreciate their critiques but as with any advice I get, the cold hard truth is I have what I have and only so much $ to put towards my chicken endeavor and will work with what I have and can afford - that's the reality of my situation. The SOP they have is their own. While I will work from it as I read it some chestnut is allowed so that's what I'll do. Also, if or when these birds ever get USA APA it is almost guaranteed the SOP will vary from the UK. I think anyone with Marans, which were only accepted quite recently though they have been around for a while knows that the UK, French and American Standards are all different, so to with Orpingtons and many others. And we all know how often one buys or hatches 'show-quality' chickens...
I fully understand the need for the cream hackle on both the male and female and I think I am starting to grasp the concept and the difference but I would personally like some chestnut in there especially with the roosters. I do prefer the creamier hackle on the boy.
Whether Greenfire got taken or did not know about the gold and bred everything together so that there is cream and gold tossed in I am really not concerned as I have what I have and that's what I've got to work with. Not sure why I would throw the baby out with the bath water when I already knew it was going to be a task breeding these birds and as Keith says hoping to improve with each generation. If there was another source that could guarantee me correct birds then that would be something else. BUT they can't even get or guarantee correct birds over there -they just have a greater availability than we do given this is a recent import and given how the price has fallen who'll import them now? I am glad I have them and glad I bought them...not to big on sour grapes, but the auto-sexing blue egg nature works for me up here in NH. I would like to think that we, all of us, are pioneers (as one person on here put it) and we chart our own course. I'm a lefty-liberal, former US Marine but this may be my personal "Boston Tea-Party" moment. LOL!!!!
This is from the UK SOP and what I am using as a guide
MALE COLOUR
Plumage, Cream Variety, Male: Neck hackles cream, sparsely barred. Saddle hackles cream, barred with dark grey, tipped with cream. Back and shoulders cream with dark grey barring, some chestnut permissible. Wings, primaries dark grey, faintly barred, some white permissible; secondaries dark grey more clearly marked; coverts grey barred, tips cream, some chestnut smudges permissible. Breast evenly barred dark grey, well defined outline. Tail evenly barred grey, sickles being paler, some white feather permissible. Crest cream and grey, some chestnut permissible.
Okay, I'm done with the soap box and will try not to jump up on it again when this comes up. If anyone advises or wants to not breed these birds and chuck'em I will not say a word but continue on with my own long-term plans...so long as the hubby's patience lets me.
Got my second Jubilee pullet today and one of the eggs under my broody is pipping and chirping. I may remove it and stick it in the bator as she killed the last one she hatched. Poor thing will be all by itself. I really did not expect anything to hatch.
Gotta put my iphone away...darn notifications
back on my soap box

I'm really not going to listen to someone in the UK tell me not to breed a bird. I appreciate their critiques but as with any advice I get, the cold hard truth is I have what I have and only so much $ to put towards my chicken endeavor and will work with what I have and can afford - that's the reality of my situation. The SOP they have is their own. While I will work from it as I read it some chestnut is allowed so that's what I'll do. Also, if or when these birds ever get USA APA it is almost guaranteed the SOP will vary from the UK. I think anyone with Marans, which were only accepted quite recently though they have been around for a while knows that the UK, French and American Standards are all different, so to with Orpingtons and many others. And we all know how often one buys or hatches 'show-quality' chickens...
I fully understand the need for the cream hackle on both the male and female and I think I am starting to grasp the concept and the difference but I would personally like some chestnut in there especially with the roosters. I do prefer the creamier hackle on the boy.
Whether Greenfire got taken or did not know about the gold and bred everything together so that there is cream and gold tossed in I am really not concerned as I have what I have and that's what I've got to work with. Not sure why I would throw the baby out with the bath water when I already knew it was going to be a task breeding these birds and as Keith says hoping to improve with each generation. If there was another source that could guarantee me correct birds then that would be something else. BUT they can't even get or guarantee correct birds over there -they just have a greater availability than we do given this is a recent import and given how the price has fallen who'll import them now? I am glad I have them and glad I bought them...not to big on sour grapes, but the auto-sexing blue egg nature works for me up here in NH. I would like to think that we, all of us, are pioneers (as one person on here put it) and we chart our own course. I'm a lefty-liberal, former US Marine but this may be my personal "Boston Tea-Party" moment. LOL!!!!
This is from the UK SOP and what I am using as a guide
MALE COLOUR
Plumage, Cream Variety, Male: Neck hackles cream, sparsely barred. Saddle hackles cream, barred with dark grey, tipped with cream. Back and shoulders cream with dark grey barring, some chestnut permissible. Wings, primaries dark grey, faintly barred, some white permissible; secondaries dark grey more clearly marked; coverts grey barred, tips cream, some chestnut smudges permissible. Breast evenly barred dark grey, well defined outline. Tail evenly barred grey, sickles being paler, some white feather permissible. Crest cream and grey, some chestnut permissible.
Okay, I'm done with the soap box and will try not to jump up on it again when this comes up. If anyone advises or wants to not breed these birds and chuck'em I will not say a word but continue on with my own long-term plans...so long as the hubby's patience lets me.
Got my second Jubilee pullet today and one of the eggs under my broody is pipping and chirping. I may remove it and stick it in the bator as she killed the last one she hatched. Poor thing will be all by itself. I really did not expect anything to hatch.
Gotta put my iphone away...darn notifications
