I happened to see a comment posted on FB by Tyler about White Welsummers. Would anyone comment? I can see both veiwpoints but the originality of the breed would be lost. In fact, might just call the "American Welsummers" if they want to go with other breeds because "Americans" are mixed or something of a throwback that is not acceptable. Like for example, a British breeder had White Welsummers but no longer breeds them anymore or sold the flock. I don't have a lot of information on that so far. The Duckwings were a recent development but not widely acceptable. Please do respect the young man's opinion, he is just merely stating his facts that as we as the breed club have NO authority to reject White Welsummers.
Tyler: Robin, I have talked to the APA and they stated that it is not up to a breed club on if a new variety is allowed. New varieties can be submitted by individual breeders directly to the APA. The WCNA doesn't vote on approval or disapproval. The WCNA can chose to support or sponsor it or not but that doesn't mean that the...y can't be standardized. I do want to say that I am not currently breeding White Welsummers but maybe in the future.
To me, if one wants to go that route, someone will have to run another club for other colors because I will not be running it or promoting it. Having the WCNA is a big job for me and Nate and if any of you want to go elsewhere for other colors like some mentioned, the Lavender Welsummers, Black Welsummers, Silver and Gold Duckwings, Whites, I would wish you well but no hard feelings at all. I know it is America, that is what it is great about it, we can be creative with any colors of birds we want...sky is the limit! However the WCNA's purpose is this: to
preserve the breed. When too many breeders going with other colors, the original stock will be small. I, too, have my dream color of Welsummers, like the blue partridge color but the egg color will suffer and possibly the conformation and disposition and type of the Welsummer may or may not be lost. I would not call them Blue Partridge Welsummers, just simply crossbreds, like the Olive Eggers! I personally do not have the space, resources to make a blue partridge color, to keep the egg color, for at least seven to ten generations to be considered a "Welsummer" so no deal with me. However I can do that with my Olive Egger project, the color much quicker and will get a sage or green egg almost everytime.
And above all, White Welsummers, IMO, are ugly and bland. Might be good for the dinner table.