ohh dont return him. I think he's far away.. he looks like a mix. They have many chicken breed names, but some breeds look so alike. He looks like a mix. He has like Langshaan (black feathers) mixed with RIR (rhode island red-red feathers)... Buckeye mixed in him too... privetthatchery site is a good place to identify breeds and they tell about each one and some are two breeds with simular charactoristics that the birds look a bit different but have names or looks alike but just different types at the same time.. idk, check it out... look under Buckeye on their. your rooster looks like that. You can browse through that site of all the pics and there are many different names. I found about that site from a local store's poster that had different breeds they had shown in the store.