I decided this spring would be my last chick order--time to wind down my chicken keeping--so picked a few each of those breeds that, over 30 years, I've enjoyed keeping and had the best experience with. BTW, this is for eggs(especially in cold weather), free ranging and ease of managing, not meat, gave up that long ago. Also all were, hopefully, pullets. They should give me an interesting final flock.
In no particular order they are:
EE's aka Ameraucanas--I like the uniqueness of the colored eggs. Actually I've kept a few of these since the beginning, find them reliable layers and gentle although don't produce especially large eggs. This is the only breed were I keep roosters. At one time I hatched chicks in an attempt to improve the egg color but lost my breeders.
Brown Leghorns--great foragers and only breed I keep for white eggs. I prefer the rose-comb since they are less apt to have frozen comb problems. However not reliable cold weather layers and not especially friendly.--usually the first birds out of the coop and the last ones in.
Black Jersey Giants-- nice, gentle birds and size-wise less apt to be fox or hawk bait.
New Hampshire Reds--great winter layers and, in my experience not tough to get to know.
Rhode Island Reds--see NH.
Barred Rocks--great cold weather layers plus one of the first chickens I ever kept as a teenager.
Australorps--one of the best layers both cold weather and age-wise that I've had experience with. I have 3 that are in their 6th year and still give me a couple of eggs per week even in the winter.
Buff Orpingtons--love the disposition and color, good layers too. If I take the time they can become pets.
Silver Laced Wyandottes--one of few light colored birds I own as I find white birds tend to be predator targets but I love their disposition and they tend to stay close to home.
Light Brahmas--another light colored bird that sticks close. I actually picked these up on a whim at
TSC but have had good experience with them.
Dark Brahmas--ordered these because of their disposition and dark color. Again, good cold weather layers and love their feathered feet.
One breed that I should have added but overlooked and when I tried later the hatchery was out of them was the
Speckled Sussex. Nice layers and really gentle birds.
I also have half a dozen "production" Reds that I picked up from
TSC in February just so they would give me early eggs. I really tend to stay away from sex-link birds (which these are not) because I find , while they lay early, they also burn out early.
Over the years I've had a lot of different breeds or different colors of the above, some with good, others with bad, experiences but the above are the ones I liked best. If I had my druthers, a couple of breeds I would have like to try but haven't would have been Marans and Whitings.