I think I was the one who brought up using the fake eggs because that worked for us. My girls didn't like the golf balls and kicked them out onto the floor of the coop. I bought fake eggs, put them in the nesting boxes, and they arranged them the way THEY wanted them. The one I have that is laying goes in there every morning between 9 and 11 and lays her yummy orb of white nutritional goodness right next to 2 lovely fake wooden eggs. I've tried moving one of the eggs out into another nesting box, and I don't know how she does it but she moves it back into HER nest and keeps both fake eggs where she lays.