BROWN!!!! I know, I know, you never know what color you are going to get, but I was disappointed that it was brown. Our first to lay was green, and we have one more that hasn't laid yet. PLEASE LET IT BE GREEN OR BLUE!!!!!!!
I have 3 EE hens, and all of them lay a very faint light brown, (which we like to call pink in order to save face) I wouldn't worry too much... they are probably the cutest hens you can have without going to silkies or cochins or something, and they are really neat birds, so... meh. Heres to the next blue/green/pink/purple polka dotted egg... whatever it is, I'm sure you'll love them anyhow.
I have three EE and I am waiting for them to start laying. Like most everyone else who buys EE I am hoping for either blue or green eggs. I knew going into this that I could end up with brown eggs but I hope I have at least one blue/green layer.
Sorry for the non green/blue egg. I stopped buying EE's and started breeding my own, only hatching out the prettiest eggs so that hopefully I'll breed out the "will they won't they lay a brown or "pink" egg." I couldn't stand it!!! Good luck getting some blue eggs, nothing beats 'um
Ugh... I hear ya... I have one of my two Ameraucana that looks like she will be laying her first egg tomorrow and I've got my fingers crossed. I wish you the best of luck on your third. At least the eggs all still eat the same, wonderfully.