Despite the broody behavior some hens are most def bad mothers. Sometimes broody behavior is a signifier that the hen has poor mothering instincts too. It happens. Whether it be through selective breeding or a lack there of. It's true some methods of baiting a broody can work but I have personally owned a handful that can't be helped. Those hens should become dinner.Did you have some eggs or fake ones under her to mentally prep her for chicks?? perhaps she can't be duped that easy. <wink> I have only done the 'bait and switch' when the broody has had eggs under her...then I may put a few chicks in under at night...if she takes to them I will then add the rest....![]()