Thanks so much. In that last set of pics, the 5th one down of the RIR is my runty girl, Rosemary. The color difference you see is really there. I still have Reba, who is in another pic, but lost Ruby this year to internal laying. Rosemary has no middle toenails and when she was laying, laid a cream colored small to med sized egg, not brown. She hasn't laid in months (she's almost 3) and I fear she's laying internally since she used to be a great layer. Rosemary is pretty typical, color-wise, of most of the hatchery RIRs I've seen. I'm glad I do own some of the better quality ones because they are just a treat to watch. You really should get some!