I ordered my chicks from Ideal, so I'm aware they will be hatchery quality & I'm ok with that. Thank you for the added info on the Barred Hollands. I knew they were a breed that was 'endangered.' I ordered 2 of each in case I get a rooster or one of the chicks dies. I guess it's a little like Noah's Ark! Hopefully they will all survive. I will posts pics of the coop when we're done & I'll report to BYC the color of the eggs
Hatchery chicks are fine IMHO. I got a little Dom pullet from Privett Hatchery through our feed store because I couldn't find a private breeder willing enough to ship me one juvenile Dom. She was an adorable outgoing little breed but we lost her to a sudden violent seizure when she was 3 weeks old. Don't know why since her behavior, growth, and appetite were all normal. My farm Mom always said chicks were delicate and you never know why some survive and some don't. We also suffered the loss of a 2-1/2 month old APA Ameraucana pullet yet her sister grew up just fine.
I'm zoned for only 5 hens so ordering a lot of chicks through a hatchery doesn't work for me. I can't use 15-25 chick minimum orders
If I was zoned I would do it the way you did through a hatchery where you can pick and choose a variety of breeds. For the most part the hatcheries do a fairly decent job of sending correctly sexed chicks. It's just the bantam breeds that can't be safely sexed the way LF chicks are sexed because the banties are so tiny and have to be shipped "straight run". Chicks are delicate and it's always a gamble on mortality. Coccidiosis or pasty butt seems to be the common ailments with hatchery chicks not hatched under a hen so research those ailments in advance so you can monitor your little ones
It is amazing you were able to find Barred Hollands and I really hope they do well for you!