Can anyone tell me if this is a leghorn or a Rhode Island white? Thanks!

TripleH23

Hatching
Mar 20, 2023
2
2
4
This is a chicken I am thinking about buying to put in with my Rhode Island Red hens. Just trying to figure out what breed it but all the pictures I’ve found are similar so I’m not sure and these are the only pictures she has sent me. Any help would be great.
 

Attachments

  • A4B79F6F-2384-4EC9-80EF-55942160EA03.png
    A4B79F6F-2384-4EC9-80EF-55942160EA03.png
    1.9 MB · Views: 25
  • FAF190E4-89E0-43CF-BF6A-EB30816E3D73.png
    FAF190E4-89E0-43CF-BF6A-EB30816E3D73.png
    1.7 MB · Views: 6
Are you both quite sure?

I'll admit I'm almost clueless about breed characteristics, but I've been reading up and learning. I've learned that the APA standard for Rhode Island Whites IS a rose comb, but there are strains that have single combs, like this one from Cackle Hatchery:
https://www.cacklehatchery.com/product/rhode-island-whites/
So.... it *could* be either breed? (Just not a Leghorn.)

I've also read that the White Rock is most commonly used for commercial egg production, weighing up to 7.5 lbs. The Rhode Island White is a newer breed, hardier, and most often kept in backyard flocks; weight up to 6.5 lbs.

So... I still think it's a Rhode Island White, due to apparently coming from a backyard flock. I could very well be wrong, though. If I AM, then please correct me so everyone can learn, and I won't perpetuate false information.

OH! And to @TripleH23, where did your seller get this bird? That might be your best clue.
And THIS great tidbit, if it IS a RIW:
I read that crossing a RIR hen with a RIW rooster produces sex-linked chicks! Pullets will be red, and cockerels will be white. Bonus! For this alone, I truly hope he is a Rhode Island White.

(I'm not inclined this morning to post all the links from where I garnered this information, but I will if anyone here thinks it's necessary. Let me know.)
White Rocks are even more commonly used in meat production. They're used to make Cornish Crosses. White Rocks are very common in backyard flocks-much more common than RIWs who are stocked by only a handful of hatcheries and those that do, only out-of-standard birds. Furthermore, this bird is massive. Not quite Cornish Cross massive but big-boned none the less. This is very consistent with a White Rock since they are very commonly over standard weight due to their selection for meat quantities when compared to other Plymouth Rock varieties. Hatchery SC RIWs are marketed towards laying and are not as course boned as this bird. I would even counter and say that with the improper comb type, they shouldn't even be called RIWs to begin with as they're missing a crucial trait of the breed (similar to EEs being marketed as Ameraucanas). Regardless even hatchery RIWs are very uncommonly sold and White Rocks are sold by many more big name hatcheries and are more common overall. When you hear hoofbeats, think horse not zebra ;)
 
Are you both quite sure?

I'll admit I'm almost clueless about breed characteristics, but I've been reading up and learning. I've learned that the APA standard for Rhode Island Whites IS a rose comb, but there are strains that have single combs, like this one from Cackle Hatchery:
https://www.cacklehatchery.com/product/rhode-island-whites/
So.... it *could* be either breed? (Just not a Leghorn.)

I've also read that the White Rock is most commonly used for commercial egg production, weighing up to 7.5 lbs. The Rhode Island White is a newer breed, hardier, and most often kept in backyard flocks; weight up to 6.5 lbs.

So... I still think it's a Rhode Island White, due to apparently coming from a backyard flock. I could very well be wrong, though. If I AM, then please correct me so everyone can learn, and I won't perpetuate false information.

OH! And to @TripleH23, where did your seller get this bird? That might be your best clue.
And THIS great tidbit, if it IS a RIW:
I read that crossing a RIR hen with a RIW rooster produces sex-linked chicks! Pullets will be red, and cockerels will be white. Bonus! For this alone, I truly hope he is a Rhode Island White.
Almost every hatchery sells white Rocks, they're more common than R.I.W but since they look identical...we'll never know.😅 Most battery birds are sex links anymore.
 
I read that crossing a RIR hen with a RIW rooster produces sex-linked chicks! Pullets will be red, and cockerels will be white. Bonus! For this alone, I truly hope he is a Rhode Island White.

I'm not going to post regarding breed as I can't add anything of use there beyond what's already been posted, I just want to point out that this is incorrect--it's the opposite cross that would make sexlinked chicks. Rhode Island Red male over silver-based Rhode Island White females is what you want. This is because females can only pass sexlinked genes to their sons, never to their daughters. Males, however, can pass sexlinked genes to offspring of either sex. The silver gene is the sexlinked gene in this equation. So the RIW being the male means ALL chicks inherit silver from him, whereas the male being a RIR and the RIW being the female in the cross means only the male chicks can inherit silver, making them distinguishable from their red sisters at hatch.

Slight edit for clarity
 
Last edited:
Thank you for all of your input! I will not be getting him. We are just looking for a rooster to put with our RIR girls to make cinnamon queens or red sex link. We aren’t new to chickens but have never really paid attention to specific breeds until now. We have a barnyard mix but are trying to get to the point where we could hatch our own next year! 😁
 
In your photos, he's got that broad-breasted, stocky appearance of a Rhode Island. But he's also got red earlobes. That makes him a Rhode Island White breed:
tic_tac___rhode_island_white_rooster_by_mintymintymid-d48hmru.jpg


White Leghorns have white earlobes and are more slender:
R.04344a66bb61bf82b623294386baac8c

Leghorn_cockerel_and_hen.jpg
 
Last edited:

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom