Beautiful!! That is a really nice rooster. Meaning the second one. Actually, I kind of like that chestnut in the saddle feathers. And the neck hackles do look luxurious, and a very nice color. If memory serves, the coloration is only 10% of the score in a judging, and sadly, we have acted like it is 100% of the entire bird. Is his head as good as the rest of him??
Had the strangest thing. My rooster comb started to bend over at the back.. Thought he was getting to be old and decrepit and gravity was taking a toll. Then yesterday it was entirely straight again and back to normal. Makes me think more and more that there is some randomness in a particular, age, season and eveN day to the number of points a rooster would score in a show. Two days ago he would have had a less straight comb, before this year, a higher tail, as a very young cockerel, not the dark barring on the chest, after the molt, darker saddle feathers...etc. That is probably one of the reasons that Grant Brereton recommends selecting breeding stock from 2year olds, you know more by that time. And you are also selecting a bit for some longevity.