Here is a cockeral from last years breedings that I am using over Mom and two Aunts. Just started collecting eggs. I would like to see a more rounded chest on this one but I love his width, open tail and size, he is a big boy for 11 mos. old. He should fill out much more, his Dad took his time.This is one I took to a show months back, his back looked so long then but his tail has come up and I think he has a fairly correct backline now.
Dad/daughter setting/hatchings are finished up for this season. First 15, 6 week old chicks went out to the adult coop last week. 3 more batches in the brooder and 2 more batches in the incubator.
Predator season has started, the peeping of the youngsters in the coop at night always brings them out. Noticed digging around one of the coops yesterday AM and first skunk of the season in the trap this AM. They will tear the youngsters to pieces if they manage to get in to the coop.
Hope everyone is doing well and HAPPY HATCHING
We are going to have to get the tails shortened up. Mine come in late to. Mine lift late also. The cockerel I had in the Avatar ended up with good lift. He was in the 30wk range then.
One of the hang ups is the length of tail. It will require an outcross to accomplish it. There is a gene that dictates this. All of us with this strain has this problem. Some with the American crosses have it, IF they selected for it. Mine came from Joe, so none of mine have it. Selecting too early in the American crosses could hurt us concerning the tails. Mine bow up late.
He is a little short. Though they should be shorter than some breeds, the legs should be centered. There is as much behind as in front. In this case the blown up tails help provide balance, but if we view the bird without it, we see it.
The shafting will give us fits if we are not careful about it.
His color is not as far off as some would say (though it is not quite right) though there should be a more harmonious blend. The wings get us. Our wings are too dark. The especially dark wings contrast too sharply with the hackles and saddles. I have some variation in breast color, and hackles etc. I do not have any variation in the wing color. Good colored wings should be on our minds.
I have heard Walt mention that there is some tolerance concerning shade. I think we could get more room for forgiveness if the wings were not so dark.
This is just an opinion, but I believe our combs are too large in the males, and too small in the females. I think it is hormones affecting to the females. The females should have just a touch more comb, and perhaps lean. The Standard calls for our combs to be medium large. I would call what we have large.
I hope this is not taken as criticism of your nice bird. I have some of the same issues. I had focused on width, depth of keel, and the breast. I was at a point to shift emphasis, but my Catalanas have had me distracted. I hope that I can start tightening up with them by this spring, and give the NHs more attention. I need an outcross for the next two traits to emphasize. The problem is I do not know of anything that I feel good about trying, and not risk my gains. I may have to play on the side. I want to shorten up the tails without losing the color in the tails, and lighten up the wings a shade, and have some variation to work on color in general. I do not want to lose the depth and width.
I hope we can get these right in time. It is a shame that they ever fell to the state that they did.